Return of the Rats: Price range Cuts Means a Free Lunch for Rodents


As New York slowly reopens, many residents have noticed a disturbing return to normal: the rats are returning, too.

And budget cuts on programs that target rats are a cause for concern that the streets will only get worse, especially in some long-infested neighborhoods.

“The trash is ridiculous and the rats are even more ridiculous,” said Tiffany Joy Murchison, 44, a public relations consultant and a resident of Bedford-Stuyvesant.

In her nearly 15 years in the neighborhood, she said the rats have never been as bad as they are now. She accuses piles of garbage left on the curb and overflowing street baskets.

“We don’t even get outside after sunset,” said Murchison.

Due to the tightening of the belt caused by the pandemic, over $ 2.2 million in rat control funds have been cut from Sanitation’s budget for 2021.

The budget agreed by the Mayor and City Council in June was met by eliminating an extra fourth day of garbage collection and reducing additional litter basket services in rat reduction zones defined by the Department of Health as part of an interagency rodent elimination program launched by Mayor Bill de Blasio three years ago started.

This program was part of a larger $ 32 million rat attack plan announced in July 2017 with the aim of reducing rodent sightings by 70% in three areas with the highest number of 311 rat-related complaints: Bedford-Stuyvesant and Bushwick in Brooklyn, Chinatown and the Lower East Side and the South Bronx.

More than $ 25 million of the funds were spent on New York City Housing Authority buildings in these areas to replace basement dirt floors with concrete and install new trash compactors.

The Brooklyn and Bronx zones had more rat complaints in July compared to the previous year, while Manhattan increased 311 calls, but the total was still lower than last year.

Rat experts say these cuts will only add to more rat discomfort, especially in areas where large numbers of rodent infestations are already occurring.

“The overriding principle in all of this is of course biological. Rats need their food just like we do, ”said Bobby Corrigan, former rodent control scientist at the city health department and renowned urban rodentologist.

“In short, rats love city budget difficulties,” Corrigan told THE CITY.

Rat program hits

Matthew Combs, a postdoctoral researcher in the Department of Ecology, Evolution and Environmental Biology at Columbia University who specializes in rodents, said the cuts are “definitely a step backwards” for what has been heralded as a holistic approach to rat control.

“I think it showed places around the world that the answer to this problem was to talk about garbage policy and change hygiene instead of doing a lot of rodenticide,” said Combs of the sanitation department’s role in the rat protection program.

“Most people in New York understand that trash is the problem with rats,” he added.

When New York City began closing in March due to COVID-19, it appeared like the rats might be on hold too. Rat discomfort decreased when people whose trash the rodents thrive reduced their outdoor activities, particularly in certain high-traffic business areas.

A rat enjoys Garbage Day in Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, Nov. 11, 2019. Peter Senzamici / THE CITY

However, in July, the city’s 311 rat complaints approached last year’s mark with 3,006 calls, up from 3,398 in 2019 while the city is still largely closed.

In 2017, the city announced that residents of the rat sanctuary could expect a number of improvements from several authorities.

These include replacing old-school wire trash cans with steel cans or expensive solar-powered “big belly” condensers, more frequent garbage disposal, and increased inspections and enforcement of rat violations by city health authorities.

The targeting of specific zones reflects that rats are not naturally commuters.

“Their colonies and their populations tend to be fairly localized,” Combs told THE CITY. “If resources are abundant in an area, that area will support a lot of rats.”

Heap of garbage

A Big Belly solar trash can in Manhattan in March 2020.

A big belly solar trash can in town in March 2020. Dan Jardine / Shutterstock

While complaints have largely decreased since 2017, reports from residents in different neighborhoods show mixed results.

Wellington Chen, chief executive of the Chinatown Business Improvement District, told THE CITY that the program had been a success.

“If this current situation had happened now and we didn’t have the Big Belly [trash cans]We’d be in big trouble, ”Chen told THE CITY.

But in Bedford-Stuyvesant, Murchison said her neighborhood is still in old, overcrowded trash bins and the city has never increased the garbage collection service.

The plumbing department confirmed that trash collection in the Brooklyn Mitigation Zone was never increased to four times a week, as was the case in Manhattan and the Bronx. But now even three days seem ambitious.

Since the summer heat began, Murchison has been running with her daughter to McCarren Park in Williamsburg on Saturday morning. “When we leave in the morning, the rubbish is gone,” she said, “and when we come back in the afternoon, sometimes the rubbish is still there.”

“I’ve never been scared of walking down the street before,” added Murchison.

In July, 311 complaints about missed garbage collection across the city increased by almost 25% compared to the same month last year.

“The budget for FY 20-21 had tough decisions across town, including at DSNY,” said Joshua Goodman, spokesman for the Department of Hygiene. “We remain committed to the rat control goals and need all New Yorkers to do their part to keep the streets clean to achieve those goals.”

The mayor’s office did not respond to requests for comment.

Efforts put on hold

Other hygiene initiatives that would have directly impacted rats’ access to a free lunch have also been suspended due to budget constraints.

Late last year, the department announced the winner of a new rat resistor design competition looking for a model to replace the green wire jars from the 1930s. According to the department, procurement for the new baskets has now been suspended. And the roadside organic waste program, which removes food from the normal waste stream, has been suspended for a year.

A row of dumpsters near the Utica station in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn, Aug. 7, 2020.

A row of dumpsters near the Utica station in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn, Aug. 7, 2020. Hiram Alejandro Durán / THE CITY

A dumpsterization program announced in early March that aims to clear piles of trash on the city’s sidewalks, a major source of rodent nutrition, has not been affected by cuts, according to the Department of Sanitation and is moving forward.

Michael Lanza, a spokesman for the city’s Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, says the rat sanctuaries are still in effect and that the agency’s pest control programs, which include rodent surveillance, inspections and fines for violations, as well as eradication, will not be affected through budget cuts.

The health department also maintains a rat information portal for tracking rodent violations, but it has not been updated since the beginning of January. Lanza said it should work again after the updates complete in late summer.

Slam dunked

Some officials tricked rats into killing their cause. Brooklyn City President Eric Adams unveiled a new dunk-tank-style rat trap last fall that could hold up to 90 dead, damp rodents.

In a statement to THE CITY, Adams said that the use of these bucket traps “reduced” rodent infestation in the Borough Hall area.

Adams, who is running for mayor in 2021, said the Department of Hygiene needs to put more litter bins on the streets and restore the roadside organic waste program.

“Failure to keep our streets clean has created a rodent infestation crisis in many communities that is contributing to a poorer quality of life for residents,” he wrote.

Jan Lee, the head of the Civic Center Residents Coalition and owner of two properties on Mott Street in Chinatown, told THE CITY that he had not noticed any increase in rat activity.

“But on the other hand, we’re not out and about at night like we used to be,” Lee wrote in an email.